Disclaimer: This post contains affiliate links. This means I may earn a commission should you choose to sign up for a program or make a purchase using my link.
Paranormal fantasy continues to be a favorite genre for writers and readers alike. It invites us into extraordinary versions of our world, where magic seeps through cracks in reality and supernatural beings walk unnoticed among us. At its best, paranormal fantasy combines the familiarity of our day-to-day lives with the awe of mythical creatures, psychic powers, and mysterious dimensions. It offers the thrill of escapism without losing the grounding emotional connections we crave in storytelling.
Yet, with so many books already out there, writers often ask, how do you write paranormal fantasy that feels fresh? How do you craft a story that goes beyond recycled tropes and predictable conflicts?
The answer lies in three guiding principles: originality, emotional resonance, and authentic world-building. In this Post, we will explore how to bring those qualities into your writing, making your paranormal fantasy feel not just different, but unforgettable.
Understanding the Core of Paranormal Fantasy
To write paranormal fantasy that stands out, you first need to understand what defines it. Unlike high fantasy, which builds entirely new worlds, paranormal fantasy typically exists within our world, but with a twist. Supernatural elements hide behind the veil of normalcy. A high school might house vampires. A coffee shop might be run by a retired witch. Ghosts might roam the local library, unseen by most, but not all.
The genre thrives on contrasts: the ordinary and the extraordinary, the mundane and the magical, the human and the otherworldly. These contrasts are what make it compelling, and your story should reflect that tension at every level.
Reinventing the Familiar
Paranormal fantasy often includes familiar figures such as vampires, werewolves, witches, demons, angels, ghosts, and other supernatural beings. There is nothing wrong with using these archetypes. The key is to do something new with them.
1. Ask “What If?”
This question opens the door to creativity. Ask yourself:
- What if vampires evolved to live off artificial blood and now run blood cafes?
- What if ghosts are a government-regulated minority with legal rights?
- What if werewolves are part of an ancient environmental protection society?
By changing the rules or social context, you create a version of the supernatural that feels new and relevant.
2. Flip the Script
Consider reversing expectations:
- Make the so-called monster the moral center of your story and the humans the real danger.
- Let your vampire protagonist despise immortality and long for a mortal life.
- Write a story from the point of view of a spirit watching over a living loved one.
Readers love a familiar setup that turns out to be something they have never seen before.
Creating a Strong Supernatural System
World-building is essential in paranormal fantasy. Your world must feel real, even when it includes ghosts in subway tunnels or witches casting spells over text message.
1. Establish Clear Supernatural Logic
Even magic needs rules. Define how it works, who can access it, and what it costs. If a character can summon a spirit, is there a toll on their health or mind? If someone shapeshifts, how do they maintain control? Rules help you keep the narrative tight and the stakes believable.
2. Decide How the Supernatural Interacts with the Mundane
Is the supernatural hidden or accepted? Are there secret communities, like enclaves of magical beings in plain sight? Does the government regulate magic, or do people dismiss supernatural events as conspiracy theories?
The way your paranormal elements blend with reality shapes your entire plot and character dynamics.
3. Include Cultural and Historical Depth
Go beyond Eurocentric folklore and pull from global myths. Yoruba spirits, Japanese yokai, or Filipino aswangs offer rich traditions that many readers may be unfamiliar with. Research thoroughly and approach with respect and accuracy to avoid tokenism or misrepresentation.
Designing Memorable Characters
Even the most imaginative world will fall flat if the characters are shallow or predictable. Your supernatural characters should feel as nuanced and layered as your human ones.
1. Define Internal Conflicts
Give your characters emotional arcs. A vampire who wants to reconnect with their lost humanity. A psychic overwhelmed by guilt after foreseeing a tragedy. A ghost who cannot move on because of unfinished love. These conflicts drive the plot and deepen the emotional investment.
2. Let Supernatural Abilities Affect Personality
A person with telepathy might struggle to maintain boundaries in relationships. A shapeshifter might have identity issues. A healer might burn out emotionally from taking on others’ pain. Tie the magic to real emotional consequences.
3. Ensure Every Character Has a Role Beyond the Romance or Plot Device
Supporting characters, especially those with supernatural traits, should not exist just to serve the protagonist. Give them their own goals, agency, and secrets. This adds realism and complexity to your cast.
Crafting a Compelling Plot
A great paranormal fantasy story is not just about cool powers. It is about the story’s stakes, structure, and theme. Your plot must be tight, even when your world is wild.
1. Build Meaningful Conflict
Combine supernatural threats with emotional stakes:
- A detective solves crimes while dealing with a haunting from their past, literally.
- A teenage witch discovers a family curse while navigating high school drama.
- A ghost hunter falls in love with a spirit he is supposed to banish.
Blending external and internal conflicts creates narrative depth.
2. Keep the Pacing Dynamic
Balance your scenes. Alternate intense action with introspective moments. Use quieter scenes to develop character relationships and reveal world details.
3. Foreshadow with Care
Paranormal plots often involve secrets and twists. Plant clues early and build suspense over time. When the reveal comes, it should feel both surprising and inevitable.
Writing with Authenticity
Authenticity is what transforms your story from entertaining to unforgettable. Here is how to write paranormal fantasy that feels emotionally and thematically real.
1. Treat Emotions with Seriousness
Whether your character is a banshee mourning a lover or a necromancer reconciling with their childhood trauma, the emotions must be raw and truthful. Let readers feel the weight of your character’s journey, not just the thrill of the setting.
2. Use Paranormal Elements as Metaphors
Magic and monsters can symbolize very human struggles:
- A shapeshifter hiding their true form can mirror the experience of feeling different or alienated.
- A ghost tied to a place can reflect unresolved grief.
- A magical power that causes harm when misused can represent the fear of losing control.
These metaphors help readers relate and reflect.
3. Keep Human Connection at the Core
At its heart, even the wildest paranormal fantasy should be about relationships, between lovers, friends, enemies, and communities. Let your supernatural elements heighten those bonds, not replace them.
Avoiding Common Mistakes
Paranormal fantasy can easily fall into cliché or confusion. Here are a few pitfalls to watch for:
- Too Much Info-Dumping: Don’t explain your entire world in the first chapter. Integrate details gradually.
- Supernatural for the Sake of It: Make sure your magic or monsters serve the plot or theme. They should mean something.
- Inconsistent Tone: Switching from horror to comedy without transition can confuse readers. Maintain a consistent emotional thread.
- Neglecting Real-World Consequences: If magic is part of everyday life, it should affect society. Consider law enforcement, religion, media, or public reaction.
Great Examples to Learn From
Looking for inspiration? Check out these books and what they do well:
- “The Raven Cycle” by Maggie Stiefvater: Combines psychic phenomena, mythology, and complex teen dynamics with lyrical writing.
- “The Bone Season” by Samantha Shannon: A dystopian paranormal series with rich world-building and high stakes.
These books stand out not just because of their fantasy elements, but because they are emotionally resonant, thematically rich, and character-driven.
Wrap Up
Paranormal fantasy offers endless room for creativity, but to write stories that truly resonate, you need more than otherworldly powers or mysterious creatures. You need a grounded emotional core, a compelling plot, a vivid world, and characters who feel as real as your readers.
Reimagine what is possible, but never forget to root your story in truth, truth of emotion, truth of experience, and truth of connection. That is what will make your supernatural tale feel not just fresh and exciting, but unforgettable.
As always, happy writing!
Newsletter Sign-Up