Disclaimer: This post contains affiliate links. This means I may earn a commission should you choose to sign up for a program or make a purchase using my link.
Paranormal romance opens the door to worlds where magic pulses beneath the surface of everyday life, where love can be a blessing or a curse, and where falling for someone might mean changing your fate. These stories offer the thrill of the unknown wrapped in the intimacy of romantic connection. Whether you’re drawn to ancient curses, haunted hearts, or forbidden desires, the magic of the paranormal provides a unique canvas for unforgettable love stories.
Here are 20 fleshed-out writing prompts to help you conjure your next otherworldly romance.
1. The Cemetery Whisperer
Every morning at dawn, 17-year-old Elara walks through the local cemetery to find peace. When she starts hearing whispers from a certain grave, she assumes it’s a prank. But the voice grows stronger and more intimate, revealing deep knowledge of her life. Soon, she begins falling for the ghost of a boy who died a hundred years ago, unaware he has one chance to be reborn, and it depends on her.
2. The Ghost in the Mirror
Ever since her parents bought a haunted antique mirror, Nia has been seeing flashes of a mysterious boy from another era. One night, he speaks to her, claiming he’s trapped and needs her help to escape. As they communicate across dimensions, their bond deepens, but freeing him could mean losing him forever.
3. The Vampire’s Librarian
Kellan is a vampire who has been alive for centuries, his emotions dulled by time. When he hires Ivy, a bright and curious teen, to catalog his vast personal library, her presence begins to stir feelings he thought he had lost. As they grow closer, Ivy discovers Kellan is being hunted by a powerful order, and falling in love with him may cost her more than her job.
4. The Lighthouse Keeper’s Curse
When her parents send her to live with her aunt for the summer, Tessa meets Corwin, the solitary keeper of a lighthouse that hasn’t been operational in years. He confesses he is cursed to relive the same summer every century unless he can make someone fall in love with him honestly. As Tessa uncovers the truth of his past, she must choose whether to break his curse or protect her heart.
5. The Demon’s Redemption
When a demon named Rael is assigned to protect a human healer as his final act before being granted freedom, he expects an easy job. But Lily’s kindness begins to awaken his buried humanity. As he questions his nature, Rael must hide his identity from the angels sent to destroy him and protect Lily from the dark powers she never knew she had.
6. The Witch’s Familiar
On her seventeenth birthday, Cass discovers she’s descended from a powerful witch whose death sparked a magical war. Her aloof cat, Grimm, transforms into a sarcastic boy who claims to be her familiar. As enemies from her ancestor’s past resurface, Cass must trust Grimm, even as her feelings for him complicate their magical bond.
7. The Haunted Letterbox
New to town, Mia is thrilled when she starts receiving poetic love letters in her mailbox. But her joy turns to fear when she learns the house’s previous resident died decades ago and the letters match his handwriting. As she investigates, she feels a growing pull to the sender and must decide whether to help him cross over or find a way to bring him back.
8. The Reaper’s Apprentice
Sixteen-year-old Arin discovers that she has been chosen to become a reaper. Her first task is to escort the soul of a charming teen boy named Jace who refuses to move on. The longer he stays, the stronger their bond grows. Torn between her duty and her heart, Arin must find a loophole before both their souls are lost.
9. The Moonlit Pact
Two werewolf heirs from rival clans are forced to enter a temporary truce to investigate a series of supernatural disappearances. During a shared full moon ritual, they unexpectedly form a bond that links their emotions and thoughts. As they navigate ancient rivalries and rising danger, they begin to fall for each other, despite knowing their love could reignite war.
10. The Time-Touched Lovers
After a violent thunderstorm, 18-year-old Emma discovers a young man dressed in Civil War-era clothes hiding in her barn. He claims to have time-slipped during a battlefield explosion. As she hides him, they grow close, but time begins to unravel, threatening to send him back for good.
11. The Spirit Photographer
Aspiring photographer Rayna captures more than she bargains for when her camera reveals ghosts no one else can see. When she photographs a mysterious boy at a train station, she realizes he is the ghost of someone who died tragically in the 1970s. With each photo, she uncovers pieces of his story and falls a little deeper in love.
12. The Curse of Echoes
Whenever someone plays the ancient lullaby written by her grandmother, Violet meets a mysterious stranger in her dreams. Each time, he looks older. He claims they’re cursed to meet across different lifetimes and can only break the cycle by finding the song’s final verse, hidden in a forgotten grave.
13. The Angel’s Fall
An angel, exiled for defying divine orders, seeks refuge in a quiet town where he meets a girl who can see the faint glow of his wings. Drawn to her quiet strength, he begins to question everything he gave up. But as heaven hunts him down, she becomes a target too, and their love could condemn them both.
14. The Forest of Lost Names
When a boy wakes up in a magical forest with no memory, he is rescued by Elen, a witch’s apprentice searching for a rare herb. As they journey together, he discovers that something in the forest wants to keep him there, and Elen may be the only person who can help him reclaim his name and his heart.
15. The Enchanted Tattoo
After getting a mysterious tattoo from a street fair artist, a girl notices it begins to shift and shimmer. It leads her to a boy who claims to be a shapeshifter bound by ancient magic. The tattoo is their connection, and now it is up to her to decide if she will break his curse or bind herself to him forever.
16. The Siren’s Song
Seventeen-year-old Maren is a siren who rescues a drowning boy during a storm, defying her people’s law. Now marked as a traitor, she hides on land and forms a fragile bond with the boy she saved. But the ocean is calling her back, and Maren must choose whether to return to her world or live as a shadow of herself.
17. The Carnival After Dark
A mysterious carnival arrives in town and only appears after midnight. Ava sneaks in and is drawn to a boy who runs the tent of illusions. He’s been trapped for years, reliving the same night, and believes Ava might be his way out. But freeing him would mean becoming part of the carnival forever.
18. The Dreamwalker
Talia has vivid dreams about a boy who insists he is real and imprisoned in the dream realm. When her dreams begin affecting her waking life, she discovers she is a dreamwalker, capable of traveling between worlds. The more she helps him, the more she risks her own sanity.
19. The Graveyard Pact
During a Halloween ritual, two teens accidentally bind themselves to the spirit of a Victorian boy buried beneath the school. As they unravel his tragic past, one of them begins falling for him, unaware that releasing his spirit could sever their connection forever.
20. The Soulbound Stranger
Alia can see flashes of the future whenever she touches someone. But when she bumps into a boy and sees nothing at all, she is both terrified and intrigued. As she grows closer to him, she discovers his soul was cursed at birth and their fates are more entwined than either of them realized.
Wrap Up
Paranormal romance gives us a space to explore timeless emotions through characters touched by magic, haunted by destiny, or rebelling against ancient rules. Whether it is a ghost who whispers love from the grave or a creature of legend who finds solace in human connection, these stories offer romance with a supernatural twist that keeps readers spellbound.
Choose a prompt that calls to you, build a world where love breaks the rules, and let your characters write their own fate.
As always, happy writing!
Newsletter Sign-Up